Posted by
Logical Party on Sunday, June 29, 2008 12:00:00 AM
I was perturbed to hear disparaging remarks regarding George Carlin because of his lack of belief in God or perceived “attacks” on religion. Mr. Carlin had philosophical differences with the existence of God not as an outsider looking in, but as one who is a product of Catholic schools and upbringing. Many things he said in his comedy routine I disagreed with, many things I agreed or at least could empathize with his point of view.
Despite one’s stance on a higher power or after life, Mr. Carlin had a good heart, vociferous, enthusiastic and energetic, especially in his later, more settled, mature life. He made the most of God’s gift, and he was a champion of the working class. He was married to the same woman for 35 years until she passed on a few years back. He had setbacks in sobriety due to her sudden loss, so for all the talk about the “free love” generation, facts are he was a sensitive, committed and devoted man.
If we don’t agree with someone we should “agree to disagree” and move on. What good is our faith if when tested we crumble or protest too much? If we perceive others to be our enemy, as a Catholic we should follow Jesus’ teachings: love thy enemy. I do not understand the ill wishes towards him by many to the point of eternal damnation, for a man who was honest with himself and is now hopefully enjoying a benevolent God who loves and understands all, even dark humor and anger, as well as “yes men.” As a fellow Catholic, we are all God’s children – even those who disagree.
David DiBello
Voice of the People for June 30 , 2008
Tuesday, July 1st 2008, 7:23 PM
Not 'all'
Hicksville, L.I.: To Voicer Rosemary Montana: George Carlin was an entertainer, a comedian, who poked fun at all religions, creeds, races, etc. He was not preaching on a soapbox. You have no knowledge of what his personal relationship with God was, so why are you so quick to judge, especially when he cannot defend his actions or words? Please do not include me when you so broadly profess that "we Catholics all remember your insults."